Week 4 of The Masked Singer was the first time our aggregation of the best internet guesses was put to the test - and we were right! Gathering the internets’ best guesses on the identities of costumed singing contestants since week 1, it’s now crunch time, updating the contestants that remain each week to see how previous guesses fare.

In the first of the internet guesses articles, Paul Shaffer was listed as the the most popular guess for the identity of Skeleton. This was correct, as Skeleton was unable to survive the increasingly competitive battles and forced to reveal his identity to the world. And it was, in fact, Paul Shaffer, David Letterman’s former musical director. Now, with the first correct guess, let’s see if the clues changed the guesses for the surviving week 4 singers.

Flamingo

Former Most Popular Guess: Adrienne Bailon

Updated Best Guess: Adrienne Bailon

New Clue Connections

This week, Flamingo referred to herself as a triple threat. This still holds true with The Cheetah Girls star, and the Route 66 reference links up well with the fact that the Cheetah Girls had a song by that name. Flamingo also made a reference to having trained for and wanting to be a medical professional when she was younger. The Real host has previously talked about having wanted to be an obstetrician, and she attended High School for Health Professions and Human Services in New York City. The apple she was holding also was a likely nod to her New York roots. Bailon’s humble beginnings and being discovered by “King of Latin Pop”, Ricky Martin also fit those clues. We’re calling this one a match and sticking with Adrienne Bailon as Flamingo.

Leopard

Former Most Popular Guess: Dennis Rodman

Updated Best Guess: Dennis Rodman or Seal

The clue package this week talked about not always being wanted and moving from pack to pack. Many thought this clue, along with a previous British accent, made singer Seal - who was raised by a foster family - an obvious choice. His 6'4" build fits with the height of Leopard. There is also, of course, a leopard seal, and while some fans thought the living life in color clue meant it was a member of the show In Living Color, others pointed out Seal had a song called “Colour.” Dennis Rodman fans have also pointed out the star was kicked out by his birth mother and considered the family who took him in to be his “adopted” family, and the color could refer to the NBA stars embracing his creative side with his ever-changing hair color. Primetime champion definitely fits with the NBA championship wins. The clues might fit Rodman a bit better, but Seal is also a very strong guess. This one is definitely split down the middle, with the singing itself throwing many off. Many believe the singing is too polished to be Rodman, but others find it not polished enough to be Seal.

Black Widow

Former Most Popular Guess: Raven Symone

Updated Best Guess: Raven Symone

The consensus on Black Widow was Raven Symone. This week’s clues seem to further support that guess - including the That’s So Raven star’s clean image and long career growing up as a Disney star. Other clues still fit as well; the platinum album, as Cheetah girls have gone platinum multiple times, the knitting, again referencing her Raven’s Home characters design career, and a can of spray paint - like the earlier painting of the peach - is a nod to the fact that Symone attended art school. This is another pretty clear one. It appears we might have a Cheetah Girls reunion going on this season!

Thingamajig

Former Most Popular Guess: Victor Oladipo

Updated Best Guess: Victor Oladipo

This week definitely helped confirm that Victor Oladipo is Thingamajig. While some clues may have been meant to mislead, like magic and rehab, fans of Oladipo were quick to point out that he played for the Orlando Magic, and rehab could be referring to physical therapy rehabilitation; the NBA player had very well documented rehabilitation after an injury. While the quality of his singing is surprising fans, they are still convinced this is Victor Oladipo.

Butterfly

Former Most Popular Guess: Michelle Williams

Updated Best Guess: Michelle Williams

The clue package seemed to support the previous guess of Michelle Williams. An obvious reference to the song “Say My Name,” as well as a mention of breakups, were a clear link to the former Destiny’s Child singer. A mention of her butterfly tattoo sealed this one.

Next: Masked Singer: The Internet’s Best Guesses at Identities – Week 3

The Masked Singer airs Wednesdays at 8pm EST on Fox.